Hudson writes on a Daily Kos diary: Here is the short version of the situation shaping up in Columbia, Murphy's strongest county in NY-20:
Tedisco's legal team is moving to disenfranchise an entire class of voters.
Specifically, virtually all ballots from Democrats who fit the profile of "second home owners" are being challenged -- and if the Board does not uphold the challenge, those ballots are being set aside, unopened, subject to a formal appeal by Tedisco. That is: They cannot be opened until a judge rules on them.
This GOP strategy is going to significantly depress Murphy's vote tally in Columbia, at least temporarily.
Those unfamiliar with Columbia County may not be aware that there has been, for many years, a large second home community here -- made up overwhelmingly, though not exclusively, of Democrats from New York City. Many of these voters have been here for many years, in some cases decades. As is entirely appropriate and legal, they have cast their ballots here without incident many times before, including just a few months ago for Barack Obama.
But as I'm hearing it, the Tedisco lawyer in Columbia (sent in by John Ciampoli) came prepared to challenge pretty much anyone who was a Democrat who had their absentee sent to a "downstate" address.
[Irony alert: As smartly pointed out in the comments by MinistryofTruth, Tedisco himself doesn't even live in the district! Yet he's challenging the residency of longtime home owners and voters here?]
Now, the legal precedent has been affirmed many times on the State and Federal level that a person who owns more than one home can pick whichever of their homes' districts they want to vote in. The law is clear: You don't have to vote at your "primary" residence, where you file your main tax return. So long as you don't register and vote in more than one place, this is 100% legal. There are many good reasons for this: The right to representation where you pay taxes, the difficulty of determining primary residence, the fact that some professionals spend a large part of the year away from their main home, etc. -- Daily Kos: {{ UPDATED x2 }} NY-20: Urgent distress call from Columbia County